Webreakstuff's blog on design, development and strategy. Click here to subscribe.

Technorati controlling the blogosphere?

Fred Oliveira on July 12, 2005

technorati Seems like I couldn’t go without posting about Technorati’s business model after reading this post on Tom Foremski’s weblog. There was something with the whole deal with Live8 that kinda messed with my head as someone who usually stays close to ground on business surrounding blogs - but what they’re pitching to corporate ears now, the “selling” of the blogosphere is something I’ve always thought about and wondered how long the blogosphere would resist without.

So, I’ll give you the skinny on what Tom Foremski goes on about (read it on detail on his post): He, Sam Whitmore and Peter Hirshberg were on a panel entitled “How the Blogosphere is changing the game in PR and marketing” (coincidently, my previous post is exactly about this). Tom “reports” how Hirshberg (representing Technorati on the panel) was pitching about how corporations could harness technorati’s blog tracking features in order to, and I quote, “control your corporate message”.

Here’s Tom’s view on it (quoted from his article):

Well, Technorati is offering services that will help companies control their corporate message by identifying those blogs and their social network, that have posted around the “wrong” message. Then, I would imagine, some sort of corporate “SWAT” team could parachute in and engage those off-message bloggers.

“You need to become involved in the conversation,” Mr Hirshberg strongly advised his audience.

I was surprised by how aggressive Technorati was in its pitch because it has a very good standing within the blogging community, a community that bristles at the thought of others commercializing its work.

This is scary. Not for lots of people who cope (and need) the business side of things, but to the average blogger, raving about products to their friends and family, carelessly posting what they believe in, unknowingly being monitored and jammed into a portfolio for marketing efforts by companies who will be paying technorati to keep up-to-date on their market.

When is a conversation (if you haven’t read my previous post, I recommend you to, because it is where I connect blogs to conversations) public, and when is it private? When is it a privacy violation to take any written content and sell it (or the statistics surrounding it)? I’ve got mixed feelings all over this.


Comments on this post

Chris Peters

The Internet is entirely public, so why should anyone be surprised that someone would scheme up such an idea? I think a blogger needs to consider such risks (amongst many others when considering potential audiences of his or her information) when parading their thoughts and ideas out in public.

fred

Even though I get your point, I’m still wondering how most bloggers would see the idea of profit being made out of their own opinions.

Your comment makes me want to point out something else. Even being what you could call “public”, not all information on the web is meant for consumption on a statistic base. I for one share my content over a CC licensing scheme which allows for derivative works (which collected statistics could tangentially be considered), but not everybody is happy about being another number being sold to create new products.

Remember I’m an apologist of free culture, free knowledge, free information and the remixing world. But not everybody is. Those are the people who’s opinions I wonder about.

Gregory Hoyl Jr.

I have been testing/building applications that act somewhat like what they have over at http://www.blogpulse.com/, using Technorati’s APIs. From a marketing POV, the news that Technorati is thinking about offering services to better “measure” brands in the blogosphere sounds great… but I can understand why this may seem scary to some bloggers.

Cheers!

TechCrunch » Blog Archive » Web 2.0 This Week (July 10 - 16)

[...] More Points of View: Dave Sifry, Syntagma, Frank Gruber, BusinessWeek, Blog Herald, ChrisWere.com, WeBreakStuff, Jeremy Wright, Jeremy Wright #2, Newest Industry, Hans on Experience, Scoble, David Berlind 2. RSS v. Atom - Tim Bray posts a comparative chart [...]

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.